Value

Line + Mass

Notan: two, three, four values

The arrangement of light and dark. If the design works at two values, it will work finished. If it does not, nothing will save it.

Notan is a Japanese word for the pattern of light and dark in a picture, independent of everything else. Reduce any landscape to two values, black and white, and you can see immediately whether the design holds: is there one big light shape and one big dark shape? Do they interlock? Does the eye go somewhere? At three values you can see the halftone that holds them apart, and at four the picture is essentially finished. More steps add polish, not strength.

Corot composed in three. His foreground is a dark shape, his distance a light one, and his midground the halftone bridge between them. Cotman designed in three or four flat shapes before he drew a single moulding. Train yourself to see every subject this way: squint until it collapses into a few flat shapes, and draw the shapes first.

The practical drill is the two-inch thumbnail: three values, no lines, no detail, done in three minutes. If you cannot make the subject read at that size in three values, choose a different subject or a different crop.

Visuals

The same landscape reduced to two values, three values and four values, showing that the design is readable at two and complete at four2 VALUESThe design. If thisfails, nothing saves it.3 VALUESCorot's working number.4 VALUESFinished. More steps addpolish, not strength.Notan: the arrangement of light and dark, Japanese for "light-dark".Squint until the scene collapses to three flat shapes. Draw those first.Every lesson in the Mass unit starts here.A drawing with a good two-value design and bad details beats one with perfect details and no design.
FigureThe same scene at two, three and four values.
Environs of Rome, Corot, 1866
Cleveland Museum of Art

Corot, Environs of Rome, 1866. etching.

Corot, Environs of Rome (etching). Squint: a dark frame of trees and ground, a light sky, a small halftone distance. Three shapes.

The Cleveland Museum of Art · Gift of Frederick Keppel and Co., Inc., The Frederick Keppel Memorial

Pitfalls

What

Starting with detail and hoping a design emerges.

Why

It never does. The values end up scattered evenly and nothing reads.

Fix

Thumbnail first. Three values. Then enlarge the thumbnail, not the subject.