Silverpoint

The Card Game

The Card Game, Menzel, 1899
Art Institute of Chicago

Menzel, The Card Game, 1899. Graphite and fabricated black chalk, with stumping, erasing, and scraping, with touches of brush and black ink, on cream wove paper, edge mounted on ivory wove card.

The Art Institute of Chicago · Gift of Dorothy Braude Edinburg to the Harry B. and Bessie K. Braude Memorial Collection

Plate copyMass

The Card Game

Menzel, 1899: a plate copy from charcoal and chalk

The Card Game, 1899: Graphite and fabricated black chalk, with stumping, erasing, and scraping, with touches of brush and black ink, on cream wove paper, edge mounted on ivory wove card, Primary support: 19.8 × 26.7 cm (7 13/16 × 10 9/16 in.); Secondary support: 26.1 × 33.5 cm (10 5/16 × 13 1/4 in.) (The Art Institute of Chicago). A plate copy: the standard protocol for charcoal and chalk applied to this one sheet at the size of your book, with Menzel's own habits as the checklist. Find the darkest passage and notice it is burnished, not hatched.

Difficulty
Time
about 2 h
You draw with
willow charcoal or 4B and 6B graphite, kneaded eraser
Charcoal: the late Corot methodThe three divisions of lightHard, soft and lost edgesSky holesErasers as drawing tools

Why this one

  • Draw what is in front of you, not what you know is there.
  • Pressure as a tool: lean on the soft grades until the paper shines, then put a hard grade over it for the edge.
  • Everything is worth drawing. A railing is as serious as a cathedral.

From your kit

The whole kit →
  1. 1Grafwood 4B, 6B 4B, 6B for the darks, on their sides for mass. Long points from the Blackwing on everything up to B.
  2. 2Willow charcoal, or until it arrives Pitt Matt 12B and 14B on their sides the matt grades are the closest graphite gets to willow. Slip sheet under the hand.
  3. 3Pitt Matt 14B, knife-sharpened stands in for the charcoal pencil: trunk, branch zig-zag, the one accent.
  4. 4Kneaded eraser (warm it) and the clean Mono Zero lift the lights out of the mass; the Mono Zero for sky holes and lit edges.
  5. 5Alpha sketchbook 9 x 6 draw at the book's size and keep the proportions; date the page.
In general, this study asks for
  • Drawing pad or cheap newsprint
  • Willow charcoal, medium
  • Charcoal pencil
  • Kneaded eraser
  • Stump

Watch first

All videos →

Permission to be loose. Watch the side-of-the-stick strokes.

YouTube
Subtractive drawing: symmetry and value in charcoalNathan Orosco · Laying a charcoal ground and lifting the lights out, the late-Corot method.Atmospheric charcoal landscape drawing tutorialMad Charcoal · Broad charcoal masses and lifted lights; the closest thing on YouTube to a late Corot being made.

The plan

4 stages · ~80 min
  1. 1

    Read the plate first

    5 min

    Before any mark, look at The Card Game for five minutes with the pencil down. Find the eye level or the horizon. Find the lightest light and the darkest dark and notice whether they touch. Count the big shapes: it is rarely more than four. Say what the picture is about in one sentence.

    Checklist0 / 3
  2. 2

    Three values, on the side of the stick

    30 min

    Break the stick to two inches. Lay the whole drawing as three flat values with the side of the stick: paper, middle, dark. No edges, no lines, no detail. Stand back after each pass.

    Checklist0 / 3
  3. 3

    Lift the lights, lose the edges

    35 min

    Kneaded eraser: lift the lights out of the masses where the original has them (sky holes, a lit trunk, the far plane). Stump or finger: lose the edges the original loses, usually at the base of things. Charcoal pencil: the few accents, last.

    Checklist0 / 3
  4. 4

    Compare and note

    10 min

    Side by side with the original: where did you add what was not there? Where did you darken what was light? Write one sentence on the sheet about what to change next time. Date it. Box it.

    Checklist0 / 2

What it should look like

  • Masses first, with no outlines.
  • Lights that were taken out of dark.
  • Soft everywhere except the two or three places that must be sharp.

Where it goes wrong

  • Drawing with the tip. It makes lines, and lines make outlines. Side of the stick for the first thirty minutes, no exceptions.
  • Grey everywhere. No true dark was committed. Put the darkest dark in early and compare everything to it.

Log this session

Start the clock when you pick up the pencil. Stop it when you put it down. Log it. Every session counts toward the box.

00:00of ~120 min

Status

How did it go?

Up nextSluice

Related studies